Resigning from Yourself
Read this chapter the way a book is read: pages that turn, and your place is saved.Open this chapter in the book

Part Three

What We Tell No One

A voice that blames you every night. Anger you swallow until you explode. A passing thought that frightens you. An “if” that steals your sleep. We hide them as though they belong to us alone. In this part, we put them on the table. We look at what is happening and separate what we can do from what lies beyond our control.

Chapter Nine

The Voice That Scolds You Every Night

Why doesn’t being hard on ourselves make us better?

About 6 minutes to read

The Loading Bar

Karim put the game back on his phone, then watched the loading bar as if he were waiting for news from someone he did not want to meet. He had deleted it a week earlier. On the night he wrote the “For my father, or for me” sheet, he had left the phone away from his pillow.

It was now past one. Someone on the team wrote, “Your spot’s still open.” Karim looked at his roommate’s bed. The duvet was still; his face was turned to the wall. Karim tapped the button to join.

The round ended. He sat on the edge of his bed and put the phone between his knees. On the floor beneath his feet lay the food wrapper he had promised to pick up before bed. The voice said, “You’re no good.” A short sentence, with a pause he recognized from the way his father spoke.

He opened the drawer to get a sheet of paper. At the bottom lay the envelope his father had given him when he left. He was afraid it might say the same thing as the voice.

The duvet on the other bed moved. “Still awake?” his roommate asked. “Going to sleep now,” Karim said, without moving. On the screen, the waiting counter climbed. Then an invitation to another round appeared.

Karim deleted the game again. He felt relieved when the icon disappeared. He pulled out the sheet and wrote, “I…” All he could find to follow it were the words he knew by heart.

He tried writing a reply to a friend who had made the same mistake. A kind sentence emerged, and he crossed it out. It felt as if he were giving himself permission for tomorrow. He went from judgment to defense, then back to judgment. He got up to turn off the lamp. The sheet still had no time, no action, no next step.

You may know this trial: you make a mistake, then start listing the evidence that you are no good. But what happens after the verdict? If it sends you back to the same action, do you need a harsher judge, or a sentence that leaves you something you can put right?

Two Sentences, a Whole Year Apart

“I made a mistake” and “I’m bad” are two short sentences. They sound alike. The difference between them changes everything.

“I made a mistake” describes an action. It happened at a particular moment. It had an effect you can work to repair, apologize for, or learn from.

“I’m bad” judges your entire self. It has no end and offers no possible repair, because it is not about an action. It is about you.

Psychologists distinguish between two feelings that sound close but have very different effects. Guilt means distress over a particular action. Shame means distress over your whole self.

Researchers June Tangney and Ronda Dearing brought together decades of studies on this difference1. They found a largely consistent pattern. People more inclined to guilt than shame often turn toward apologizing, making amends, and trying not to repeat the action.

People overwhelmed by shame are more likely to deny what happened, blame someone else, or become angry with whoever reminds them of their mistake. Sometimes they return to the very same action, simply to escape the shame.

Why Does Harsh Blame Bring You Back to the Same Place?

Psychologist Paul Gilbert founded what is known as compassion-focused therapy. In his book The Compassionate Mind he asks a question that may seem strange at first2: why does your body treat a harsh word from inside as a real danger from outside? Because harsh self-criticism activates a response in the body similar to its response to actual danger.

Gilbert calls this defensive system the “threat system.” Your body wants to escape the feeling rather than face the action. The nearest escape route is the habit you know will numb it, even for a few moments.

Gilbert also describes another system, which he calls the “soothing system.” Here, your body calms down enough for you to face the mistake, without running from it or from yourself.

What, then, is the alternative to this threat system? Researcher Kristin Neff pioneered research on self-compassion. In her book Self-Compassion she describes it through a simple example3: after a mistake, treat yourself as you would a friend who made a mistake. Self-compassion does not mean justifying the action or no longer regretting it. It means acknowledging it calmly, without turning it into a judgment on your worth as a person.

Researchers Juliana Breines and Serena Chen tested this idea in several experiments. In one, they asked participants to remember a time they had wronged someone. In another, they gave them a difficult test on which they performed poorly.

Writing in a compassionate way increased the desire to make amends. Encouraging self-compassion increased the time participants spent studying for a later test. Depending on the experiment, the comparison groups worked on boosting self-esteem, used a positive distraction, or received no intervention4.

The findings extend beyond a single moment in a laboratory. Researcher Michael Wohl and two colleagues followed university students before two successive exams in the same course5. Forgiving themselves for putting off studying for the first exam was associated with less self-reported procrastination before the next. Here, forgiveness went with a quicker return to studying rather than more delay.

﴿قُلْ يَا عِبَادِيَ الَّذِينَ أَسْرَفُوا عَلَى أَنْفُسِهِمْ لَا تَقْنَطُوا مِنْ رَحْمَةِ اللَّهِ﴾ Say, "O My servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning], do not despair of the mercy of Allah." (Az-Zumar 39:53)6

Notice who is being addressed. Not “the righteous,” but “those who have transgressed against themselves”: those who have made many mistakes, not just one. Yet the address begins with “O My servants,” rather than a harsher word.

A Friend’s Voice

When to use it: After a mistake that you turn into a judgment on your entire self. Time needed: Five minutes to write, then one step within the next hour.

Try this tool when your inner voice puts you on trial:

  1. Name the voice. When you hear a sentence like “I’m no good,” pause. Tell yourself, “This is the voice of judgment, not the voice of truth.”
  2. Ask: What would I say to a friend? Imagine a friend you love telling you they did exactly the same thing. Write the sentence you would say in reply. It probably would not be “You’re no good.”
  3. Describe the action, not the identity. Write what happened as a statement of fact, not a verdict: “I did this at this time,” rather than “I’m a failure.”
  4. Remember that you are not alone. Many others have had the same relapse, even if they never told you. This does not justify the action. It takes away the illusion that you are the only exception.
  5. Choose one small step now. Not a promise of perfection. One concrete action within the next hour: go to sleep, take a short walk, or message a friend.

If you fall: Describe the new action in one line, then choose your next step. Do not rewrite the verdict against yourself.

Two weeks later, Karim returned to the game on a difficult night. He heard the old sentence and began writing a reply. He filled half a page before he noticed: he had started another trial, just in a calmer voice.

He read the “If you fall” line. He drew a line beneath his words and wrote, “I opened the game at one ten and stayed for forty minutes.” He named what had happened, then looked at the clock. His next step was to drink some water and sleep.

In the kitchen, he found his roommate waiting for the water to boil. “Going to keep playing?” he asked. “No. I lost forty minutes, not the whole night,” Karim said. He filled his cup and said nothing about his lists from previous years. “Turn off the hallway light on your way back,” his roommate said.

He turned off the hallway light and passed the desk. The envelope stayed in the drawer. Opening it was not tonight’s step. He pulled the duvet up to his shoulders and fell asleep.

Before You Sleep

Write in a notebook, or anywhere that will not distract you, and answer honestly:

  1. What does your harsh voice usually say after a mistake? Write it exactly as you hear it.
  2. If a friend said it about themselves in front of you, what would you say back?
  3. What small step can you take tonight instead of passing a final judgment?

On the night he was leaving for home, Karim looked back at the drawer three times before turning off the light. He carried his bag to the door, then came back for his phone charger and left the envelope behind.

References (6)
  1. 1Tangney, J. P., & Dearing, R. L. (2002). Shame and Guilt. Guilford Press.
  2. 2Gilbert, P. (2009). The Compassionate Mind: A New Approach to Life's Challenges. Constable.
  3. 3Neff, K. (2011). Self-Compassion: The Proven Power of Being Kind to Yourself. William Morrow.
  4. 4Breines, J. G., & Chen, S. (2012). Self-compassion increases self-improvement motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38(9), 1133–1143.
  5. 5Wohl, M. J. A., Pychyl, T. A., & Bennett, S. H. (2010). I forgive myself, now I can study: How self-forgiveness for procrastinating can reduce future procrastination. Personality and Individual Differences, 48(7), 803–808.
  6. 6The Quran, Az-Zumar 39:53. Verse text.